In what could be chalked up as another win for Nintendo Down Under, Australian Customs and Border Protection Service officials have seized an incoming shipment of R4 cartridges, which can be used with Nintendo’s DS to play pirated games.
The seizure is detailed in an IT Wire story from the future, which notes that a question of the legality over selling the R4 carts in Australia now exists following Nintendo’s victory last month over an Australian website that sold the devices.
While it was originally reported that Nintendo’s beef with RSJ IT Solutions (which operates the site GadgetGear) was settled in court by a judge, later updates indicate that the $520,000 AU fine levied was not actually handed down by a judge, but that the case was settled out of court. Adding to the confusion, the case was settled “in such a manner that the Judge was still permitted to pass down an order.”
Getting back to this recent case, customs said that it seized the goods under “the Notice of Objection Scheme in the Trade Marks Act 1995,” adding that it “regularly” attempts to find counterfeit Nintendo products entering the country.
A Nintendo spokesperson told IT Wire that customs officials will send it photos of suspected counterfeit goods and Nintendo responds with its take on whether the products are counterfeit or not. Once goods are taken, the importer of the products can object to the seizure, but this has apparently “never occurred.”
So, for this one particular case, what exactly happened? A customs official attempted to sum it up:
On 29 January 2010, Customs and Border Protection seized approximately 150 items suspected of infringing Nintendo’s trademarks. In accordance with this Scheme, the importer agreed to forfeit these items to Customs and Border Protection. Customs and Border Protection will dispose of these forfeited items.
The decision to take legal action is made by the registered objector. The court will determine any penalties that would be imposed.
Relatedly, in a bid to show that R4 cartridges have uses other than to play pirated content, the website R4DS put together a list of the top ten homebrew applications for the DS.
Site operator Adam Ulivi stated, “These are games and applications that talented hobbyists make and distribute for free on the Internet. Most people are unaware that they can actually get free, legal games, because the pirating capabilities of the R4 tend to overshadow its positive capabilities.”
A PUBLICATION OF THE ECA
SUBSCRIBE
LOGIN / REGISTER
Comments
Another intersting differnce between the US and AU.
Could you imagine a US importer rolling over and playing dead that easily?
This is why I hate the US, AU, and every other country that has the R4 and related devices as illegal. PIRATING is illegal/wrong, NOT USING A DEVICE THAT HAS MANY USES. That's like banning computers because you *could* download ROMS/Emulators to it. >.>
-Optimum est pati quod emendare non possis-It is best to endure what you cannot change-
The difference is that the pc wasen't made for piracy, the R4 was.
http://www.magicinkgaming.com/
Lockpicks are made for lockpicking, and most of the time are used for illicit purposes. That doesn't mean that they should be illegal to own as long as you aren't using them illegally, because there ARE legitimate uses for them.
-Optimum est pati quod emendare non possis-It is best to endure what you cannot change-
Lockpicks are an interesting example, or more specifically, the locksmith industry.
If you follow the history of the locksmiths, they have, countless times, tried to make thier own tools illegal for anyone other then their people to use, as well as restrict information about how locks operate (including long standing design flaws that actually made picking MUCH easier) via legal threats.
There have also been attempts (some would say successful since it is on a per-complaint basis) to outlaw general purpose computer intrusion tools like scanners and crackers that are used by network security professionals.
We are just one CNN piece about someone using lockpicks to rape and kill a photogenic teen from those being made illegal (or at least licensed) given today's attitudes.
So the Shoutbox doesn't work for me. When I try to add comments, it goes to this weird white screen with a couple of links and the ESRB box and then just stays there.
AE: Try deleting the contents of the "Your Website URL" box before posting.
*Edit* To Andrew Eisen: What should instead be done is NOT have Under God in the pledge, and if you WANT to add it in then you can. Under God wasn't added to the pledge until the '50s as a response to the USSR's official secular policy. Atheists/Communists were viewed as "enemys to the state" (and sadly still are today by many Americans), so the '50s Congress based several unconstitutional references to the *Christian* god in our currency/pledge.
(I've also taken to crossing out "In God We Trust" on currency)
Edit again* To JDJK: Having "God" the way that it's written is advancing/endorsing monotheism *over* polytheism/pantheism/deism (which is funny, because many founding fathers were deistic themselves).
It'd be like having "In White Men We Trust" on our currency because most of our government leaders are white men. It's descriminatory based on your beliefs, and divides our country between "Good Christian Americans" and "Heathen Atheist/Pagan scum."
-Optimum est pati quod emendare non possis-It is best to endure what you cannot change-
Thanks AE, heh. ^-^
-Optimum est pati quod emendare non possis-It is best to endure what you cannot change-
Since when is Australia the "Capital of everything bad on Videogames"? Nintendo suing on any looser with a PC, crazy ass politicians, internet censorship, anti-free of speech douches. Damn it. It´s so ridiculous.
------------------------------------------------------------ My DeviantArt Page (aka DeviantCensorship): http://www.darkknightstrikes.deviantart.com